Skip to content

Unisex Toilets? Is there a problem with this?

19 September, 2013

toilet

All day, every day, I hear toilet stories.

Women not wanting to ever use a public toilet, children refusing to actually go to the toilet through the day because the toilets are disgusting, (dark, dripping taps, wet floors, spider webs, hard toilet paper, no toilet paper, no soap, the list goes on). But I was astounded and amazed with the news yesterday that a new Queensland Government initiative will be Unisex toilets at newly built schools. The fear that boys will be in the toilets ‘listening’ to what the girls will be doing in the toilet stall next door will be worrying and off-putting for the girls and some will defer and hold on to extreme lengths rather than risk that thought of being heard to either urinate or pass wind. I see a number of children who have continence issues (both bladder and bowel) who have to use the toilet to deal with that incontinence and that would be beyond embarrassing to do that with someone from the opposite sex watching.

Worse still, many 10 and 11-year-old girls are getting their periods and I can’t imagine how awful that would be to have to go into the toilets with boys standing around washing their hands and talking, with a girl attempting to change their pad or tampon. I understand the reason the need for this change in direction is because of issues with trans-gender children being able to access an appropriate toilet, but I feel there would be a way to assist those children in a sensitive way on an individual basis at each school, rather than create a potential catastrophe with both girls and boys feeling anxious about using mixed toilets at school. As a physiotherapist who treats bladder and bowel issues in women, men and children every day, I can assure you many of our adult problems commence in childhood with bad habits, anxieties and myths perpetuated from generation to generation. But I never thought I’d have to problem-solve how to get around mixed toilets…….It just won’t work and we shouldn’t have to make it work!

I would hope there has been adequate consultation with the appropriate health and teaching professionals when considering a decision such as this. And I really hope that this decision wasn’t driven by any financial rationalism.

Advertisements
2 Comments
  1. Allison permalink

    I agree, Sue – adolescence is awkward enough without worrying about boys/girls in the stall next door, especially with the inadequate toilet doors that are often fitted.
    I often recommend to post-prostatectomy patients to use the disabled toilet for pad changes etc, and surely that would be an appropriate option for transgender students.

  2. Janet Walter permalink

    Thanks for drawing this to our attention Sue, I also agree with Allison’s comment. If toilets have to to be unisex they would need to cater for privacy, and I don’t think this would happen in a school environment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: